Nappy Myths

Congratulations to hunters who are still going!  What better to post about on the Great Down Under Nappy Hunt than some cloth nappy myths?  Hopefully this will be reassuring for newbies and give the regular users some ammunition, and of course you can add your own comments!

  • Cloth nappies are hard work. My Mum had three in nappies and an old twin tub machine that had to be changed over and filled by hand. It wasn’t earthed properly and almost electrocuted her. So absolutely, for her cloth nappies were a lot of hard work. I have a lovely modern washing machine and lovely modern detergent and my nappies are made from lovely modern fabrics and are super absorbent. So for me it’s an extra load of washing every two or three days. Frankly, going to the shops and buying disposables (remembering to buy them!) would be harder and more time consuming.
  • They’re hard to put on. I’m terrible at putting sposies on, I also have problems with velcro. But I can do a snappi in about 2 seconds flat. My point is not that one is easier or harder, but that we learn what we are used to. You are going to be doing at least 5 changes a day for around 2 years, possibly much more. Do you really think you’ll take 3650 goes to learn how to do it easily? Or do you think it will be simple after a week or two?
  • Cloth nappies are unreliable. When you look at the elastic around the legs, at the front and back and different fit options, there’s no way anything is getting out. There are some brands that don’t suit some babies, and of course if you don’t use a water resistant layer of some sort you’re going to get wet. So I suppose my caveat here is that an appropriate, well fitting system is completely reliable. It may take a bit of experimenting, but there will be a way of doing it. Ignoring the hype and talking to other Mums says that sposies have problems too – at least there are lots of cloth options to play around with, not the 5 or so that sposie users have.
  • They have to be changed often. Ummmm, isn’t that a good thing? Do you really want your baby sitting in wee?
  • They cause nappy rash. Nappy rash is caused by the bacteria from poo changing wee into ammonia, which burns little bums. So if you don’t want nappy rash, change and wash your baby with something mild. In the 50’s it was practically unknown. Of course individual babies have different reactions – some react to disposables, some react to fleece, some react if they aren’t breathable enough. If you have a rashy baby you’re going to have to experiment.
  • They make it harder for babies to roll, crawl and walk. There is a huge normal age range for mobility, unless there is something wrong they all get there.  My bubbas walked at 10 and 11 months and climbed pretty much immediately, so if cloth nappies slowed them down I’m eternally grateful – can you imagine if it was earlier?

And because we have to have an environmental one in there,

  • They use lots of water. Think modern washing machines. Think only 40 or so nappies actually used, so not that much in materials. Think dry pailing, so no soaking water needed. Then think where the paper used in those 3650 disposables came from. Cloth nappies use more of your water, so probably not a good idea if you are on tanks, but overall it’s much less clear.
Advertisements

One response to this post.

  1. Posted by Teresa on September 28, 2009 at 8:56 pm

    DS rolled at 8 weeks crawled at 4 1/2 months and now at 8 1/2 months is nearly walking… cloth nappies sure haven’t slowed him down – if the have thank god for that!!! congrats on a fantastic blog!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: